Posts

Thriving As A Massage Therapist During Pregnancy

Barefoot and pregnant…in my massage room.

As soon as I finished massage school, I kicked off my shoes and socks and have massaged in my bare (clean) feet ever since! I just feel more comfortable barefooted: grounded, comfortable and stable. I prefer to be in bare feet at home and while squatting and deadlifting too!

What I didn’t expect was I was setting myself up for some seriously achy feet late in my pregnancy!

However, my sore, tired feet were definitely the least of my pregnancy worries while working as a Massage Therapist. I finished working at 35 weeks pregnant and now at 37 weeks I am nesting, resting, enjoying working out and being outdoors before baby arrives.

Many of my amazing colleagues and friends gave me fantastic advice on how to survive pregnancy while working as a self-employed RMT. It’s hard to know how you will feel while pregnant, but I thought I would share some of this wisdom and some personal experience of my own.

It is important to note that every woman is different and every pregnancy is different. So what worked, or didn’t work for me may not be relatable to you! The number one rule of being pregnant: Listen to your body!

How to Thrive During Pregnancy

Before pregnancy – There are a few things I suggest are important to consider before becoming pregnant.

  • Maternity leave – To pay into Employment Insurance (EI) or not, that is the question as a self-employed therapist! This is an extremely personal decision and I think it’s important for each person to do their own research and discuss with their partner. (Government of Canada Employment Insurance information). It is important to know that in Canada once you start paying into EI, you must continue to do so for the remainder of your self-employed career.

In my life, it was a better and simpler decision to work hard at saving money to allow myself a few months of maternity leave and have my partner, Shaun, take parental leave which he is entitled to through his work. What an amazing opportunity for him to bond and spend time with our son or daughter!

My flexible plan is to go back to work two half days a week after being off work for five months. This will obviously depend on how my family is doing and if, mentally and physically, I feel ready!

  • Mental Preparation – Honestly, I have struggled being pregnant. While I’m so grateful and excited for Shaun and I to be having a baby soon, I have struggled with the lifestyle change more than I expected. Growing another human is HARD!! Much harder than I expected. I do wish I had mentally prepared myself a bit more for the fact that I might have to slow down more than some women have to, that I might feel nauseous every day, that I may not sleep well and that I needed to gain more weight than I thought I would. Again everyone is different, but I do think it is important to note that some of us will find it a big change from what life is normally like.
  • Get strong – I cannot believe how good my body has felt during pregnancy! I have had almost zero complaints about aches and pains during and outside of work. Maybe I’ve been lucky, but I actually think it has a great deal to do with the fact that I was/am fit and strong. Strength training is a huge passion of mine, and the benefits have clearly served me well during pregnancy. Being able to lunge, squat and press helped me stay strong at work. Having strong posterior muscles (glutes, erectors, rhomboids, etc) have helped me to stay balanced with all the extra weight that I have gained on the front of my body. Having a strong core also makes it easier to support yourself while leaning over and onto a massage table.

Trimester 1.

Oh the hormones, nausea and exhaustion! Luckily, not every woman experiences a terrible first trimester and I hope you are one of them! Unfortunately, I was not so lucky. Here are some tips on making it through!

  •  Scheduling – are you able to be flexible with your schedule? They call it morning sickness, but many women experience it in the morning, the afternoon or the evening or in my case all dang day! If you are able to schedule your clients during the times that you feel the best, I suggest doing so.
  • Eating – nausea and food aversions are a challenge for anyone. But for a massage therapist with a hard, physical job, food is necessary to keep you energetic! In my case, if I didn’t eat, I threw up. My strategy became to eat a few bites of food after each client. This seemed to keep my nausea controllable and my energy high. Find things that are appealing to you and snack on them all day. Most recommended were high protein foods that would keep me feeling fuller longer and blood sugars stable.
  • Planning – soon you will be telling everyone that you are pregnant! So exciting! So this is a good time to think about how long you would like to work. Your clients will want to know so they can take full advantage of you while they can!

Trimester 2

I hear most women start feeling really good during their second semester: a lot more energy and a decrease in morning sickness. Time to take advantage!

  • Scheduling – If you’re feeling good and are trying to save money for maternity leave, I suggest trying to work as much as you’re comfortable, while not overdoing it. Likely, you will want to drop your hours down during your third trimester.
  • Eat healthy and Eat often My trick was to make a large healthy meal (or normal for me before pregnancy) and divide it into two or three smaller meals. I would then eat these smaller meals throughout the day to keep my energy high. This also helped with my constant nausea. I ate like this my entire pregnancy. Remember you’re nourishing not only your body but your baby as well!
  • Constant advice – be ready for opinions and unwanted advice from EVERYONE! I have to say, most of what I experienced was fantastic and useful advice!  You will be flooded with people being excited for you and maybe some clients making you feel a bit guilty about going off work for a while (“can’t you just bring baby to work with you?”). Remember everything is your choice and you should do your own research into what is best for you, your body, your baby and your family.

Trimester 3  

As baby grows, so will you! This may leave you feeling heavy, large, hot, fatigued and starting to get uncomfortable. Lucky for me I have had a lot of energy during my third trimester and my arms are long and ape-like so I didn’t find massaging uncomfortable. I actually loved going to work and worked five days a week until 35 weeks! Sure, I decreased my hours a bit but I was still doing four to five 60 minute massages a day. Working helped keep my mind off of being nauseous and my nervousness of labour and delivery.

  • Grow some thick skin – People will tell you anything and everything while you’re pregnant. I had comments on my body: “You need to get a handle on your weight gain” and “I hope you’re still exercising.”  A lot of comparison with other women: “Oh my sister was way sicker than you” or “my friend was still running until 37 weeks.” The horror stories of birth: “36 hours of labour and 4 hours of pushing and she still had to have a caesarian section.” And the tough love: “It’s not about you anymore.” My normally overly sensitive self was left feeling down and defeated after some comments. While some things can be hard to hear, at some point, you have to just let it all go and know you’re doing your best.
  • Put your feet up One of the best pieces of advice was someone telling me to book a significant break in my day to put my feet up. I found in the last month of working I needed to sit down and put my achy (and still bare!) feet up for least 20 minutes. It’s also a great time to eat and cool down (baby makes your body feel like a furnace!). Sometimes longer breaks are good for fresh air or having a quick nap if needed.
  • Listen to your body – This has to be the best but also a challenging thing to do. Some women will feel amazing their entire pregnancy and will work a lot more and longer than I did!  Some women will be a lot more active than you and I are. And some will need to be on bedrest or stress leave. Everyone is different, so do what is best for YOU!

Photo by: Meaghan Mounce

Other Things To Consider

  • Stay active – If you were into some activity before pregnancy, try to continue to do some form of it during. You have a physical job and you need to keep up your strength and endurance for it! You are about also about to do the most challenging workout of your life when labour begins! I think it’s very important to be fit and strong to push out a baby, recover well after a vaginal or caesarian birth and take care of your new baby and yourself. At 37 weeks pregnant, I still strength train 2-3 days a week. I crave fresh air and so I walk most days. I swim and oh man, does it feel good! Do what you enjoy, but  again listen to your body.
  • Electric table – I was so lucky to be able to work with an electric table. The further my pregnancy went along, the higher I needed to set my table. If you have access to one, use it.
  • Your memory might suck! – There were times where I questioned whether I had massaged the other side of the body already, where I couldn’t remember the name of an easily identified muscle and had no clue the name of the person on my massage table. It is and was such a weird feeling! One trick I did use with new clients was to say their name several times within the first few minutes of meeting them. It seemed to help solidify their name to my memory during the massage!
  • Be Proud – You are growing another human and that takes a lot of work, physically, mentally and emotionally! My favourite piece of advice came from my good friend and fellow massage therapist, “Be gentle with yourself. You and your body are doing amazing things and you should be proud!”

What Is Involved In Being A Massage Professional?

Okay, I get it, this might be an ironic post coming from me but I’m taking a different approach on this one.

There are many facets to being a professional and many of them are talked about online and in forums.

Being a professional in our industry means staying up to date on CECs, being mindful of our therapeutic relationship with patients, perform care in an ethical manner and generally be a good therapist.

There is endless amounts of information you could look up on the topic and I’m sure most colleges and associations have outlines on their websites for your reference.

However what there isn’t a lot of information on is being a professional, within your profession and dealing with your colleagues. Again this is a topic that could probably be written about over and over again with a wide array of opinion.

I would just like to cover two of the topics that I see as important.

Supporting The Less Experienced

I have been fortunate enough over the last two years to attend a couple of different conferences on manual therapy and various aspects of it.

Each time I have been able to walk away with some new knowledge, understanding, or just made some great connections with other therapists. When I heard Jason Silvernail speak at one of the conferences he made a GREAT point at the end of his discussion (I’ll quote him the best I can from memory).

“Now that you have a better understanding and more knowledge, it is your responsibility to take it home and share it with your peers.”

This isn’t just applicable with hearing new information and sharing it. It should also be applied to the profession in general. Getting started in this profession can be pretty difficult. Many factors come in to play when deciding, how to start in practice?, how to be in business for yourself?, what are quality CECs to take?

It is our responsibility to share all of this kind of information with our peers. Whether this is done online or in person, the more experienced in our industry need to share that knowledge with new grads. We have written on this blog before about using mentorship programs, following quality blogs, creating meet ups and other ways to help in this regard.

Being professional means pulling ahead those behind us, to actually pull the profession forward. We need to inspire, educate and share with those who are starting to fill the profession. As an industry massage therapy has come a long way in the last 20 years and continues expanding and progressing. There are people who led the way in this charge long before most of us were around, now it’s our responsibility to keep the momentum going.

One of the main ways to do this is by supporting and helping those with less experience, so that we never regress as a profession.

Photo by: bianca_89

Duty To Report

It’s funny the things you remember from growing up.

I was always told that if you have an issue with someone you go directly to them first and try to deal with it and if you can’t resolve said issue, then get help from an outside source and attempt to deal with the issue that way.

In our case, when we are dealing with one of our colleagues, we have a duty to report if there is an issue with them. According to our provincial bylaws (I realize this will be different everywhere, so just using it as an example) we are required to report someone if we believe another registrant could bring harm to the public as a result of their not being competent due to mental health, emotional issues, or addictions that could impair their ability to practice, or they have been hospitalized for the above reasons. And of course we have a duty to report sexual misconduct.

However, outside of these reasons we should conduct ourselves a bit differently.

Professional courtesy has a few different definitions, depending on which field you are in but essentially it’s a way of showing professional etiquette between you and your colleagues. With doctors it has meant treating the families of colleagues, in law enforcement it could mean letting a fellow police officer off the hook of a speeding ticket.

So what should it mean to us?

I dare say, we’re not treating other Massage Therapists families for free, and we don’t deal with speeding tickets.

When we’re talking about professional behaviour and etiquette being extended between colleagues, this also means we should be up front with them. All too often we see therapists demeaning others online or making misleading statements about associations without knowing the whole story behind a specific topic. Publicizing wrong or hurtful information online is not only harmful to you as a practitioner it’s harmful to the profession. If you think a fellow therapist (or association for that matter) has done something unprofessional contact them directly to discuss it. If it is not a serious infraction like the ones laid out in the duty to report, offer enough professional courtesy to speak or message directly with them. Calling up your college or association and making anonymous complaints about unprofessionalism is well…unprofessional. It is not the job of your association or college to regulate everything, it is also up to us as professionals to self regulate.

 

What Is Really Contraindicated With Diabetes?

A little while ago we wrote a piece on circulation and whether massage is actually moving fluids around and increasing circulation.

As it turns out, we aren’t increasing circulation the way we used to think was happening (you can read that post here if you like).

One thing that came up as a result of that post, was the question of whether we need to decrease the length of our strokes when giving a massage in certain conditions?

Looking back through my textbooks and notes from college, conditions like diabetes and hypertension were given similar contraindications. In fact with diabetes CI’s it was recommended that massage strokes are modified to short, segmental strokes to prevent large volumes of venous and lymphatic fluid return to the heart. It is also recommended that repetitive, passive large limb movements should be avoided as well.

So are these CI’s really necessary?

Stroke Length

When someone has diabetes and blood glucose is high for extended periods (years), then plaques can form in blood vessels causing damage and impaired blood flow to neighbouring cells. This is called Peripheral Arterial Disease (PAD).

This poor circulation can be one of the causes of peripheral neuropathy along with excess body weight and high blood pressure. 

One study showed that using massage therapy helped increase circulation in the lower limbs of type II diabetic patients with improvements in arterial pressure and greater skin blood flow. Fortunately the study acknowledged the parasympathetic nervous systems role. Indicating decrease in heart rate and a rise in oxygen saturation. This study was done to see if there were improvements in peripheral arterial disease and fortunately it showed that massage could help slow the disease progression. 

This study used very specific treatment patterns using both long and short strokes to the back and the lower limb of the patients. But notice they used both long and short strokes. 

As we learned in the post we did a little while ago, during a massage we aren’t increasing overall circulation anymore than the circulation increased by the person walking into your clinic. So how then would altering the length of your stroke make any difference?

I’d venture to say it doesn’t.

As far as passive large limb movements being CI’d, again there is no way it is altering circulation more than the effort it took to walk into the clinic. If professional athletes like Bobby Clarke and Max Domi can play hockey at the professional level while managing their diabetes, a passive limb movement during a massage isn’t going to cause much of an issue.

Centpacrr at English Wikipedia [CC BY-SA 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0) or GFDL (http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/fdl.html)], via Wikimedia Commons

Ketoacidosis And Diaphragmatic Breathing

Ketoacidosis occurs in diabetics when their cells don’t get the glucose they need (due to a lack of insulin, or too much insulin resulting in low blood glucose), the body starts to burn fat as a replacement.

As this process develops, ketones can build up in the blood (ketones are an acid developed from burning fat) which then changes the pH balance in blood making the balance too low, where it becomes more acidic. This in turn sends a person into diabetic shock, which is a life threatening emergency. A person with diabetes can have this happen for three reasons:

  1. Missing a meal.
  2. Stress or sickness.
  3. Insulin reaction (low levels of insulin in the bloodstream).

We were told in college that diaphragmatic breathing was a contraindication for our diabetic patients as it could cause ketoacidosis. From the textbook we were taught “To compensate for a tendency towards acidosis, the person may need to breathe more rapidly. Diaphragmatic breathing may actually change insulin levels”.

Now, don’t get me wrong, I give full props to the authors of that text as there was lots of good instruction in it, but research has been updated since then.

According to diabetes.co.uk rapid breathing is a symptom of ketoacidosis, so this is typically occurring if the person hasn’t taken enough insulin. So yes, if the person is at the point of breathing rapidly we should not be giving them a massage as this is now becoming a medical emergency.

One study (1) actually showed that diaphragmatic breathing is an effective therapy for decreasing oxidative stress, improving blood sugar levels after eating, and improving glycemic parameters overall for those with type II diabetes.  

Another study (2) (done on people without diabetes) showed that diaphragmatic breathing decreased glycemia and increased insulin production after a meal (likely through activation of the PNS). The study suggests that even though it was done on athletes, it is worth looking at for the diabetic population because of the outcomes.

Now I know what you’re thinking, those two studies showed that diaphragmatic breathing altered insulin and blood sugar levels…isn’t that exactly what the text was talking about?

Well it is, but we were taught it was a contraindication. Studies are now recommending that the diabetic population should be using diaphragmatic breathing.

Our actual concern should be timing of food intake before someone with diabetes comes in for a treatment. If someone hasn’t eaten for three or four hours and comes in, their breathing patterns are not what is going to cause them to have a diabetic reaction, it’s the fact their blood sugar is already too low. There is nothing about the massage that is going to accelerate that anymore than if they were walking down the street or sitting on the couch at home. This is an important discussion to have with your patients who are dealing with diabetes and definitely one you should have. Once a proper management schedule is established, go ahead and move them passively, use diaphragmatic breathing and whatever length of stroke you like, they are all things that can help improve their condition.

I’d love to hear your thoughts on this in the comments below, especially if you know of any current research that says we shouldn’t do any of the things discussed in this post, cause maybe I just found the wrong research?

 

References:

  1. Hegde S, Adhikari P, Subbalakshmi N, Nandini M, Rao G, D’Souza V. Diaphragmatic breathing exercise as a therapeutic intervention for control of oxidative stress in type 2 diabetes mellitus. Complementary Therapies In Clinical Practice [serial on the Internet]. (2012, Aug), [cited May 1, 2017]; 18(3): 151-153. Available from: CINAHL Complete.
  2. Martarelli D, Cocchioni M, Scuri S, Pompei P. Diaphragmatic Breathing Reduces Postprandial Oxidative Stress. Journal Of Alternative & Complementary Medicine [serial on the Internet]. (2011, July), [cited May 1, 2017]; 17(7): 623-628. Available from: CINAHL Complete

Is Exercise Appropriate During Pregnancy?

Pregnancy is supposed to be a time for joy, anticipation and new experiences.

But for a lot of moms it also comes with a lot of anxiety and questions. With all the blogs, articles and social media confusion, moms are forever wondering if they are doing the right thing. For women that like to exercise, they often wonder how much is too much, what’s safe and how they should modify their activity?

The good news is exercise is both safe and encouraged for most pregnant women!

Exercise Recommendations And Cautions

Unless a woman has certain high risk conditions (bleeding, cardiac issues, fetal growth restrictions) both The American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) and Society of Obstetricians and Gynecology of Canada (SOGC) recommend daily exercise.

In 2015 ACOG published guidelines recommending pregnant women get 20-30 minutes of exercise daily. Exercise should be at a moderate intensity level, which means you should be slightly out of breath but still able to hold a conversation. Regular exercise maintains physical fitness, helps with weight management, reduces the risk for gestational diabetes in obese women, and enhances psychologic well-being. Furthermore, exercise in the year prior to conception decreases the risk for pre-eclampsia.

For a mom with an exercise program in place, she can continue to exercise with appropriate modifications. Women can continue walking, lifting weights, swimming and even running to a certain extent.

It is recommended to stop activities where mom may fall on the abdomen or something may hit the abdomen after the first trimester (such as racquetball). Other activities may just need modifications.

For example, if mom is a biker, she may want to consider no longer using pedal clips after the first trimester. Then if she loses her balance it is easy to place a foot down to avoid a fall. The safest option is to move indoors and ride on a trainer or stationary bike. Many women can continue to run as long as they listen to their body. Women may have to change the “goal” of their activity and focus on exercising to be active in pregnancy, not run/bike/walk for certain mileage or speed. It’s extremely important she listen to her body for signs of fatigue, pain, or changes in fetal movement.

Yoga and Pilates is often encouraged during pregnancy. Both have been found to decrease stress levels in moms, improve common pregnancy pain complaints, and improve effectiveness of breathing.

If a mom has been performing yoga or Pilates, little modification is needed. She may want to avoid inversion (head below hips) positions and large asymmetric movements (movements where legs are going in opposite directions). As the baby grows, having the hips above the head for prolonged time can put pressure down and potentially disrupt normal blood flow and breathing patterns. Most moms that have been practicing Pilates and Yoga can tolerate these positions for short time periods without issues. If a mom experiences dizziness, shortness of breath or a headache, it’s recommended she stop these positions. If new to Pilates or Yoga, she should take a class specific to pregnancy with a trained instructor and consider starting with an individualized session or two.

Photo by: seandreilinger

Photo by: seandreilinger

Setting Up New Habits

Many moms use pregnancy as the time to start new healthy habits. We love that!

For moms starting a new exercise routine, walking is generally the safest cardiovascular activity. Light free weights or machines are a great way to start strengthening. Strengthening should focus on the muscles of the arms, upper back and leg muscles. Balance may be affected by pregnancy but strengthening and exercise is a great way to decrease fall risk. So the take home message is don’t be afraid to have your patients keep moving during pregnancy! If a mom is unsure how to start a routine or modify her routine, this is where you can help. If exercise prescription isn’t in your scope of practice, refer her to someone qualified to set up a program. Exercise has many benefits to mom and baby, so keep moving!

 

References:

ACOG Committee Opinion No. 267. Exercise during pregnancy and the postpartum period. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Obstet Gynecol. 2015;99:171-173.

Artal R, O’Toole, M. Guidelines of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists for exercise during pregnancy and the postpartum period. Br J Sports Med 2003; 37: 6-12.

Barakat R, Pelaez M, Montejo R, Luaces M, Zakynthinaki M. Exercise during pregnancy improves maternal health perception: a randomized controlled trial. American Journal Of Obstetrics & Gynecology May 2011;204(5):402.e1-7

Beddoe A, Yang C, Kennedy H, Weiss S, Lee K. The effects of mindfulness-based yoga during pregnancy on maternal psychological and physical distress. JOGNN: Journal Of Obstetric, Gynecologic & Neonatal Nursing. May 2009;38(3):310-319.

Dempsey J, Butler C, Williams MA. No need for a pregnant pause: physical activity may reduce the occurrence of gestational diabetes mellitus and preeclampsia. Exerc Sport Sci Rev. 2005 July;33(3):141-149

Moran-Perich S, Benson E. Power Pilates: Empowering Your Pregnancy. 2004 June.

Deconstructing Magical Thinking

 

Most of us have had the experience that somehow we “knew” something that we did not have specific prior knowledge of. It’s tempting to start indulging in magical thinking but the science-minded therapist knows that’s not how it works. So how does it happen? One obvious answer is pure coincidence. Another less obvious answer is unconscious learning.

Todd Hargrove wrote one of my favorite articles on the subject, “Why Massage is Like Chicken Sexing.” In it he describes how unconscious learning can lead us to believe in magical thinking. I’d never really thought about it but he had a good point.

In fact, I came to realize that probably most of our learning is unconscious. We learn to talk by being immersed in language and, little by little, learning to decipher what is being said by those around us without applying conscious effort. While our parents may try to help us learn to walk, the fine points of balance and running and adapting to varying terrain are learned by experience rather than specific attention to them.

The placement of buildings and trees in our environment is something we may not purposely attend to but our brain is still taking in this information. If something in our environment changes it catches our eye, even though we may not have paid much attention before.

Intuition Vs. Experiential Knowledge

About five or six years into my professional life I reached an uncomfortable plateau.

Until then, it seemed I was constantly learning new things, always progressing, but I started to feel as if I were stagnating, even going backwards. One day, while giving a massage to a more experienced massage therapist I voiced this. She said to me, “You must be learning something because you keep stopping in all the right places.” I had no idea I was doing this.

It occurred to me that my brain, through my hands, must have been picking up subtle cues that my conscious mind did not notice.

Years later there were other experiences, one with a competitive skier. About ten minutes into a massage he commented that he could tell I was very experienced. I asked him exactly what made him say that since I was just warming up and not yet doing anything specific. He he told me, “I can feel you adjusting and changing your pressure in the places that are tight and sore.” Again, I did not realize I was doing this.

The occasion that particularly stood out was with a dancer. He was the oldest member of his dance troupe and had been with them the longest. He was taciturn and clearly tired. I asked him how he felt. “Tired. Sore. Too much jumping,” he said in his Slavic accent. He pointed to a few places and lay down on the table. As I was massaging the back of his upper leg, I felt something that got my attention and the thought popped into my mind, “Old injury.” I’m cautious about what I say to athletes and performing artists prior to their performance, I don’t want to undermine their confidence in any way. Although I would never say it anyway, one should never say, “Wow! You’re really tight!” shortly before a performer is going onstage. I asked him, rather casually and neutrally, “How does this feel?” “Hurts,” he said, then added that he’d pulled a hamstring jumping. “When was that?” I asked. “Two years ago.” Wow, I thought, did I nail that or what?

Of course, it doesn’t always work like that but it was a cool moment. Later, when I told another massage therapist about it, they asked, “How did you know that?” I started thinking, exactly how did I know? Intuition? But what is intuition? Is it some sort of magic or is there a plausible explanation for it?

Then an answer came to me: my hands have been on thousands of bodies for tens of thousands of hours in varying states of injury and pain and no pain. Without my conscious awareness, my brain is paying attention at every moment. There is a large body of experiential knowledge. Probably something felt similar to other old hamstring injuries I’d felt many, many times before.

Or maybe it was pure coincidence.

Photo by: StockSnap

Unconscious Learning And Accumulated Massage Experience

Unconscious learning probably plays a much larger role in our lives than we realize.

Is this any less awesome than thinking some sort of magic is at play? I don’t think so. It’s incredible that our brain can do that and very useful, too. If we had to put conscious effort into every single thing we learned, we wouldn’t learn very much at all.

All of these intuitive moments came about as a result of years of accumulated experience. In the beginning, sometimes someone more experienced would palpate something and point it out to me. “Here, feel this?” I would have no idea what I was supposed to feel. I had no body of experience (or enough experience of bodies) that allowed me to interpret what I was palpating. It’s important for beginning massage therapists to understand this and not become frustrated if they feel lost. It’s also important that one should not be overeager to jump to conclusions prematurely.

Too often, massage therapists are quite certain they feel things that are simply a product of their imagination, what has been called “palpatory pareidolia.” (Pareidolia is seeing patterns where none exist, such as seeing a face in a rock or a horse in a cloud.) Palpatory pareidolia can lead a therapist to pathologize normal tissues, causing unnecessary worry to the client or making themselves look ill-informed.

We want to avoid making assumptions so they don’t get in the way of seeing what is, rather than what we imagine. We want to be fully open to the client as they are, not as what we project onto them. However, as we gain many hours of experience with many, many clients, we can develop a kind of knowledge which we think of as intuitive that is probably a result of many years of unconscious learning.

In practice, when an idea comes from that intuitive place, I always check with the client, asking in a neutral manner so as not to alarm them or lead them to an answer. After all, I could easily be wrong.

The next time you have a moment where you seem to sense something without knowing why, take a few minutes to think about what past experiences or cues may have led to that. It may not be immediately apparent, but if you contemplate it for awhile you may get some clues. It will help you appreciate the role unconscious learning plays in your life. Pretty amazing, isn’t it?

Why Massage Is Like Chicken Sexing

I’ve written before on my blog about how manual therapists can develop some very questionable ideas about exactly how they are helping their clients. Like thinking they can manipulate energy fields, chakras, chi or cerebral spinal fluid patterns. Interestingly, my own observation is that many therapists who believe the craziest things actually get some pretty good results! How could this happen? How could they get good results without knowing how they do it?

There are probably very many good explanations. I thought of a new one while reading an excellent book called Incognito, by neuroscientist David Eagleman.

The theme of the book is that most of the activity of the brain is completely inaccessible to our consciousness. The brain is thinking and solving problems all the time, and our conscious selves basically have no control over these processes or even knowledge of them. We become aware of answers to problems long after our subconscious brain has been working them out.

The conscious brain is like a CEO who is handed a final product that has been slaved over by thousands of workers for years. The CEO might have provided some general guidance for the basic process (and might even take all the credit afterwards) but he or she knew nothing about 99% of the actual work that went into making the product.

So when problems are being solved and things are being figured out, the conscious brain is often the last to know. Which brings me to the topic of chicken sexing.

CHICKEN SEXING

When chicks are born, farmers often want to figure out which ones will be someday be laying eggs and which should be fattened for meat. Deciding whether a chick is male or female is much harder to do than you might imagine, because chicks are more androgenous than a 1980s pop star. So farmers hire special employees called chicken sexers to determine who’s a boy and who’s a girl.

The interesting thing is that many of the world’s best chicken sexers seem to have no real idea at all how they make the call. They just pick up a chick, look at its butt, then decide that it’s either male or female. When its time to train a new chicken sexer, they don’t give the trainee a procedure to follow or a set of criteria. They just tell the trainee to look at the chick’s butt, ask them to make the call, and then tell them if they are right or wrong. Sooner or later the trainee learns to make reliable decisions, but never develops any conscious understanding of how they do it.

CARD PICKING

Similar principles can be seen in a more controlled and scientific environment. In one interesting study, volunteers were asked to pick a card from one of two decks. Some cards were “good” and provided monetary rewards while others were “bad” and caused losses. Further, one deck contained more bad cards then the other. The question for researchers was: when would the players learn which deck to pick from?

It took players about twenty five draws before they stated a preference for one deck over the other. But their unconscious brains figured things out much quicker. How do we know? Because the researchers monitored physiological data from the players’ skin to determine the state of their autonomic nervous systems (the “fight or flight” system.) After as few as thirteen picks, players were showing some anticipatory fear prior to choosing a card from the bad deck. In other words, they were already getting an accurate idea about which deck was bad, before they had any conscious awareness of having that knowledge.

BACK RUBBING

I think that many massage therapists are kind of like chicken sexers. Their unconscious brains figure out what makes clients feel better without ever gaining any conscious awareness of how they do it.

A massage therapist needs to make many decisions every minute. Where do you push, how hard, at what angle, at what frequency, for how long, and with what part of your body? Many therapists will deny that they have any specific criteria for answering these questions, or even that they consciously consider them at all. They just start working and their hands seem to have a mind of their own.

And if you ask them what they are doing, they might not be able to give any kind of specific explanation. Whenever I asked my Rolfing teachers what they were doing when they were giving a demonstration, they usually said something like: “I’m having a conversation with the shoulder”; or “I’m listening to the hip” or something similarly ambiguous. They really didn’t know exactly what they were doing or why. But they were definitely doing something right, because when they put their hands on you, you knew right away they were experts.

CONSCIOUS INCOMPETENCE

The lack of conscious awareness over the actual methods used in a massage session might have some advantages. When you are learning a new skill, you need some level of conscious attention to perform the skill. But once you get good at it, the unconscious takes control, and at this point, too much conscious involvement can hurt performance. This is why you can sabotage your skills with too much self conscious analysis. Imagine trying to hit a pressure putt in golf while thinking about whether you breathe out at the point of contact.

This reminds me that Ida Rolf (the creator of Rolfing) and Moshe Feldenkrais, (the creator of the Feldenkrais method) each recommended that their students avoid an analytical mindset during sessions. Rolf sometimes admonished students that they were too “in their head.” Feldenkrais stated that in order to be optimally effective during a session, he had to think as much as possible in terms of creative imagery as opposed to formal logic. Even though both Rolf and Feldenkrais were trained scientists, and each proposed scientific explanations for why their methods worked, each wanted to get as far as possible from their scientific and analytical minds during a session.

I think part of what they were doing was making sure that their unconscious brains were in charge of the session, because most of the knowledge of “what works” was stored there, inaccessible to the conscious brain. They didn’t want their conscious minds to interfere with the process.

I think this goes along way towards explaining why many therapists seem to have no idea why their therapy works, why they are attracted to explanations which are magical as opposed to scientific, and why some are even hostile to very idea of applying science to massage at all.

To put it another way, I think that it is in the large gap between knowledge and awareness that magical thinking creeps in.